Hilton Head vs Myrtle Beach: Which City is Best For You?

South Carolina’s coastline is dotted with stunning beaches, charming towns, and vibrant communities—but when it comes to choosing between Hilton Head and Myrtle Beach, the decision isn't always easy. Both offer beautiful coastal living, world-class golf, and plenty of sunshine, yet they each have a distinct personality.

Whether you're dreaming of a retirement move, looking for a second home, or just exploring your options, it’s important to understand what sets these two destinations apart. In this guide, we’ll compare Hilton Head vs Myrtle Beach to help you discover which coastal gem best fits your lifestyle and homebuying goals.

Myrtle Beach vs Hilton Head: Key Differences

Myrtle Beach and Hilton Head may share the same shoreline, but their vibes are worlds apart. 

Myrtle Beach

Myrtle Beach is known for its vibrant beach town energy. It’s a hotspot for those who thrive on activity, with a lively boardwalk, amusement parks, theaters, and a buzzing nightlife scene. If you love entertainment, festivals, and always having something to do, Myrtle Beach delivers in spades.

Hilton Head

Known for winding trails, quiet beaches, and preserved natural spaces, Hilton Head offers a slower-paced charm that feels more refined and relaxed. With upscale resorts, boutique shopping, and award-winning golf courses, it’s ideal for those seeking tranquility and a close connection to nature. It’s a favorite for retirees and families.

Things to Do in Myrtle Beach vs Hilton Head

When it comes to activities, Myrtle Beach and Hilton Head each offer unique experiences tailored to different lifestyles and interests. 

Myrtle Beach

Myrtle Beach is packed with high-energy attractions perfect for families and thrill-seekers. You’ll find amusement parks, water parks, mini-golf courses on nearly every corner, and the famous SkyWheel overlooking the ocean. Live entertainment abounds with dinner shows, concerts, and comedy clubs, while shopping hotspots like Broadway at the Beach and The Market Common keep visitors busy off the sand. If you're traveling with kids or looking for nonstop action, Myrtle Beach has you covered.

Hilton Head

Hilton Head, on the other hand, is made for those who love the outdoors and a more refined experience. Its miles of scenic biking trails are perfect for exploring at a slower pace. Kayaking through salt marshes, paddleboarding along quiet waterways, or taking a dolphin-watching tour are popular activities. Hilton Head also offers upscale dining options, adding a touch of luxury to every outing. If you're seeking peaceful, picturesque adventures, Hilton Head takes the lead.

Hilton Head vs Myrtle Beach for Golf Enthusiasts

If you search “Myrtle Beach vs Hilton Head golf”, both come up as top-tier destinations—but they cater to different kinds of players. Myrtle Beach is known as the “Golf Capital of the World,” offering an impressive volume and variety of courses. With over 90 golf courses in the region, there's something for every skill level and budget. Beginners and casual players will appreciate the relaxed atmosphere, scenic layouts, and affordable green fees that make it easy to enjoy a round or two.

Hilton Head, on the other hand, is synonymous with golf prestige. Home to renowned courses like Harbour Town Golf Links—host of the PGA Tour’s RBC Heritage—Hilton Head offers a more refined and challenging golf experience. Many of the island’s courses were designed by legends like Pete Dye and Jack Nicklaus, featuring lush landscapes, tight fairways, and strategic layouts that appeal to serious golfers seeking a true test of skill. 

Climate and Seasonal Differences 

Hilton Head and Myrtle Beach both enjoy the appealing climate that draws so many to South Carolina’s coast—mild winters, warm summers, and comfortable temperatures during spring and fall. While both cities share similar weather patterns, there are a few subtle differences that can influence your coastal living experience.

Myrtle Beach typically experiences slightly cooler temperatures than Hilton Head throughout both the summer and winter months. If you prefer a touch of relief from the summer heat, Myrtle Beach might offer a more comfortable seasonal edge. Rainfall patterns also differ slightly: Myrtle Beach sees its peak rainfall in July, whereas Hilton Head’s rainiest month is August.

Cost of Living and Lifestyle Differences

When comparing Hilton Head Island vs Myrtle Beach, cost and lifestyle are two major factors to consider. Myrtle Beach generally offers a more affordable cost of living, with lower housing prices and a wide range of budget-friendly amenities. This makes it an attractive option for budget-conscious buyers, especially those looking for more value in new homes.

Hilton Head, in contrast, leans toward a more upscale and quiet lifestyle. With its luxury communities, preserved natural surroundings, and refined atmosphere, it tends to attract retirees and those seeking a slower, more peaceful pace of life. While home prices may be higher, many buyers find the added serenity and exclusivity worth the investment.

Dream Finders Homes in Myrtle Beach and Hilton Head

Whether you're drawn to the vibrant, budget-friendly energy of Myrtle Beach or the upscale charm of Hilton Head, Dream Finders Homes offers thoughtfully designed communities to match your lifestyle. You’ll enjoy modern features, flexible floorplans, and prime locations no matter which community you choose. 

In the Myrtle Beach area, you’ll find everything from rare spacious homesites at Fowler Estates in Conway to luxury three-story townhomes at Promenade at Grande Dunes in Myrtle Beach. There are communities such as Rivertown Landing that are perfect for first-time buyers, or low-maintenance communities like Villas at Sandridge that are ideal for active adults. 

In the Hilton Head/Bluffton area, there’s a range of opportunities, from upscale homes and serene surroundings in Bailey’s Cove on Hilton Head Island to gated luxury and classic architecture at
Oldfield in Okatie. Magnolia Park in Hardeeville blends Southern charm with resort-style amenities, while River Oaks in Okatie offers family-friendly homes and a strong sense of community.

Myrtle Beach or Hilton Head: Which Should You Choose?

It can be a bit overwhelming to narrow down the exact place for your new home. Myrtle Beach vs Hilton Head? Each has its own unique set of pros and cons depending on your personal preferences and needs. Before settling down, there are sure to be a ton of questions running through your mind.

Skip the endless research. Connect with Dream Finders Homes for help in answering some of the questions you may have when relocating to Myrtle Beach or Hilton Head.